Showing posts with label $165 billion pension fund bailout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label $165 billion pension fund bailout. Show all posts

Friday, August 13, 2010

Obama boasts about what some call "a terrible precedent"

General Motors plans an initial public offering as soon as today -- a first step in the government's effort to sell its ownership stake to private investors. The IPO comes on the heels of a much publicized plant tour by President Obama, who'll certainly hail the stock sale as proof he made a smart decision by bailing out the automaker with billions of taxpayer dollars.

But, to us, the IPO will be proof of something else: a White House that purposefully trampled the legal rights of investors -- many of whom, like us, are small savers -- to benefit its political supporters. Rather than a model of success and foresight, the GM episode is a model of corruption and cronyism.

Let's review the sordid history. Last year, the federal government bought a majority stake in GM for about $50 billion -- a sum equal to GM's market capitalization in 2000, when it was making record profits.

It should hardly be a surprise that the new GM, with so much money to work with (plus a special $16 billion tax benefit) would start inching into the black again. After all, Ford, without government help, has posted after-tax earnings of about $4.7 billion for the first half of this year -- more than twice GM's, even with the $1.3 billion second-quarter profit that "Government Motors" announced yesterday.

The bailout's announced goals required a more limited intervention than what Washington concocted. For example, a deal could have been brokered with strategic investors, as in a normal distressed sale, with GM's assets -- including its valuable Cadillac and Chevrolet brands and an expanding foothold in China -- passing from weak hands to strong.

But the fact that the administration mainly solicited advice from bankruptcy experts, rather than those in industry, is evidence that alternative solutions weren't considered.

Instead, politicians ran the company their way -- raining taxpayer money on key electoral states like Michigan and rewarding their staunch financial backers in the United Auto Workers union.

The devil, in this case, was in the details of the bankruptcy plan that the government pushed through:

Bondholders -- investors ranging from large institutions to retirees just scraping by, who loaned GM a total of $27 billion -- received just 10 percent of the company. By contrast, the government's $50 billion gave it about 61 percent.

And the union -- in return for the $20 billion that GM owed its health trust -- got a remarkable 17.5 percent of the stock plus $2.5 billion in cash plus $6.5 billion in preferred stock carrying a dividend of about 9 percent.

In other words, the UAW got three to four times as much as the bondholders for a smaller claim on GM's assets. The union even boasted to its members in May 2009 that it had made no concessions on pay, health care or pensions in the restructuring.

In effect, the government divided up GM's creditors into favored and unfavored groups, then gave a fat stake in the reorganized business to the favored (a k a longtime Democratic Party donors). On top of that, Washington also ordered the shutdown of 1,650 GM dealers and another 1,000 Chrysler dealers as part of its takeover.

In last month's audit, TARP's inspector general criticized the Treasury Department for that very decision. Treasury didn't show why the cuts were "either necessary for the sake of the companies' economic survival or prudent for the sake of the nation's economic recovery." The move "substantially contributed to the accelerated shuttering of thousands of small businesses."

Remember this as the president brags about recent gains in auto-industry jobs: Even though some plants have added union jobs, many in the dealerships have been lost.

But our main concern is what happens going forward. A terrible precedent has been set.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Flawed $36 billion AIG bailout would have paid for 47 years of breast cancer research or eight Nimitz-class aircraft carriers

Today the Congressional Oversight Panel released a new report on the fall 2008 bailout of AIG, and its findings are damning for the federal regulators responsible for the bailout. The report claimed that the bailout has had a "poisonous" effect on markets, and released this laundry list of regulatory malfeasance, from the Huffington Post:

· Policymakers had several options to resolve the firm's troubles, rather than a "binary" choice of bailout or failure;

· Federal regulators could have acted earlier, potentially saving taxpayers from a $182 billion investment in the giant insurer;

· The government-led private-sector effort to save the firm primarily relied on just two financial firms and a small group of law firms rife with conflicts of interest;

· Policymakers involved in the rescue continue to change their public rationale for rescuing AIG with taxpayer cash, perhaps for political considerations;

· Even more foreign banks than previously disclosed were direct beneficiaries of the taxpayer bailout;

· It was "unlikely" a more muscular regulatory agency would have caught the insurer's problems given that the firm's own management didn't know what was going on;

· And despite the panel's mission of auditing how the government responded to its biggest intrusion in the financial markets since the Great Depression, some firms, including Goldman Sachs, which taxpayers bailed out with $10 billion in cash and nearly $21 billion in debt guarantees, continue to refuse to turn over key documents, the panel said in its report. Goldman faces a multitude of investigations regarding its subprime-era practices.

One of the Panel's members, J. Mark McWatters (who replaced Rep. Jeb Hensarling), added some details about the AIG bailout's cost to taxpayers in the report:

Other than the bailouts of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the rescue of AIG has required the allocation of more taxpayer funded resources than any other similar action undertaken by the government since the inception of the current economic crisis.

McWatters then notes that the CBO has quadrupled its estimate of the cost of the TARP investment in AIG just in the past few months, from $9 billion to $36 billion, a troubling fact considering that market conditions have only improved since the bailout was initiated. He also adds some context to those numbers:

As I have done in prior reports, I think that it is instructive to add some perspective to the magnitude of the loss the taxpayers may suffer as a result of the AIG bailout. By comparison, for fiscal year 2011 the National Institute of Health (NIH) has requested $765 million for breast cancer research, and the latest Nimitz-class aircraft carrier commissioned by the Navy cost approximately $4.5 billion. It is entirely appropriate for the taxpayers who funded the TARP program to ask if the bailout of AIG with a CBO estimated cost of $36 billion merited 47 years of breast cancer research or eight (8) Nimitz-class aircraft carriers. The "guns v. butter v. AIG" comparisons clearly demonstrate that our national resources are indeed limited and that the bailout of AIG will require the government to reduce expenditures, increase tax revenue or both.

Thursday, May 27, 2010

U.S. Labor Party using federal funds to repay unions for campaign contributions that put Democrats in power

Unions: Those who give to politicians expect a lot in return. That's clear from the budget-busting payoffs directed largely at organized labor by Democrats in Congress and the White House.

A bill making its way through the Senate would bail out union pension funds to the tune of $165 billion. The bill's author, Democratic Sen. Bob Casey of Pennsylvania, wants the public to pay for the gold-plated union retirement benefits that the funds have mismanaged into oblivion.

This has to be galling to average working saps who watch as their 401(k)s and IRAs plummet, only to be asked to pony up billions of dollars in subsidies for unionized workers — many of whom get to retire into the lap of unlabored luxury while still in their 50s.

Casey's bill isn't the only gift that the White House and Congress have for the unions. Last year, economist and columnist Ben Stein estimated that as much as half of the $862 billion stimulus would go to unions, directly or indirectly. Even that might underestimate organized labor's take.

And just last week, the White House proposed $23 billion in aid to states for education. For education? Well, in point of fact, increased federal involvement in education has had zero positive effect on test scores.

So this money has nothing to do with "the children" or schooling. It has everything to do with teacher unions, which will see billions in payouts from money ostensibly intended for school kids.

In short: bailouts for the unions; higher taxes and penury for you.

So beholden to the unions have the Democrats become, it's fair to say they are a de facto Organized Labor Party — a far more accurate name than "Democrats."

Don't agree? According to OpenSecrets.org, 12 of the 20 biggest spenders on public elections since 1989 have been unions. In just the 2008 election alone, unions spent $400 million dollars. Virtually all of it went to Democrats.